10 Best “That Guy” Actors Who Defined the 1990s (2023) Release Date

10 Best

Remember that iconic Leonardo DiCaprio meme where he hilariously points at the TV screen? Well, brace yourself for a trip down memory lane as we dive into the enchanting world of ’90s shows and movies. Get ready to spot all those familiar faces that made the era truly unforgettable. These actors, known as the ultimate chameleons, effortlessly jumped between comedic, horror, and various other genres.

Dubbed as the elusive “that guy” due to their name recognition conundrum, their faces were etched in our minds. But fear not, for many of them have now achieved household name status. Let’s take a moment to revel in the magic these performers brought to the ’90s. And hey, don’t forget to show some love to your absolute favorites!

Oh, and just a friendly heads-up: Back in the pre-internet days, tracking box office figures wasn’t as foolproof. So, consider the mentioned “box office totals” as mere rough estimates. Now, let the nostalgia-filled journey begin!

1. Steve Buscemi

Steve Buscemi
Number Of Projects: 49

Total Box Office: $1.5 billion

How He Owned The ’90s: In the ’90s, Steve Buscemi may not have been a household name, but his face was definitely familiar. With his unique appearance, he landed numerous eccentric and offbeat roles in major hits like Con Air, Armageddon, and Pulp Fiction. It’s safe to say that Buscemi boasts one of the most remarkable filmographies ever. Few actors can claim to be a regular presence in films directed by Quentin Tarantino, the Coen Brothers, and even Adam Sandler.


2. Wayne Knight

Wayne Knight
Number of Projects: 32

Total Box Office: $3.2 billion

How He Dominated the ’90s: Wayne Knight was the ultimate go-to performer when it came to quick-witted funny guys and character voices in ’90s films, both live-action and animated. Seinfeld fans will instantly recognize him as Jerry’s arch-nemesis, Newman. However, he truly made his mark as Dennis Nedry, the guy who unintentionally unleashed dinosaur chaos in Jurassic Park due to his greed and inability to keep gates closed.


3. Kathy Bates

Kathy Bates
Number Of Projects: 32

Total Box Office: $2.9 billion

Kathy Bates dominated the ’90s with her incredible range, effortlessly nailing every role she took on. Undoubtedly, her most iconic performance from that era was as the menacing Annie Wilkes in the film adaptation of Stephen King’s Misery. However, it’s worth mentioning that many people also remember her for her memorable turns in Fried Green Tomatoes and Titanic. Let’s not forget that she achieved the impressive feat of receiving an Academy Award nomination for her role in Primary Colors while also starring in The Waterboy during the same year.


4. James Cromwell

James Cromwell
In the ’90s, James Cromwell made his mark in the entertainment industry with his versatile acting skills. He effortlessly portrayed both strong and serious characters, as well as lovable and caring individuals. With a total of 39 projects under his belt during this decade, Cromwell left a lasting impression on audiences.

His performances in films like Babe, The Green Mile, and L.A. Confidential captivated viewers and contributed to his immense success. These movies, among others, collectively brought in a staggering $1.5 billion at the box office.

Cromwell’s ability to captivate audiences with his on-screen presence made him a household name in the ’90s. It’s highly likely that almost everyone has come across at least one of his films from this era.


5. Larry Miller

Larry Miller
Number Of Projects: 40

Total Box Office: $1.2 billion

How He Owned The ’90s: Larry Miller deserves some serious recognition for his incredible acting skills, as he truly brought magic to the screen in the ’90s. From his memorable roles in Pretty Woman and Mad About You to The Nutty Professor and 10 Things I Hate About You, Miller consistently elevated the quality of every project he was a part of. It’s a shame that some actors never get the appreciation they deserve, but Miller’s talent shines through nonetheless. Moreover, his portrayal in the 1998 horror remake Carnival of Souls is absolutely chilling and deserves more recognition than it receives.


6. Christopher McDonald

Christopher McDonald
Christopher McDonald, the versatile actor, has worked on a staggering 54 projects throughout his career. His contributions to the film industry have earned a grand total of $552 million at the box office.

When it comes to dominating the ’90s, McDonald is a name that cannot be ignored. He has left his mark on numerous mainstream comedies from that era. You’ll find him playing memorable characters like the infamous antagonist Shooter McGavin in Happy Gilmore, or taking on supporting roles in beloved films such as Grumpy Old Men and Flubber. McDonald’s presence was ubiquitous throughout the ’90s, becoming a familiar face to moviegoers everywhere.


7. Dan Hedaya

Dan Hedaya
Number Of Projects: 54

Total Box Office: $1.8 billion

How He Owned The ’90s: In the ’90s, Dan Hedaya became the go-to guy for playing shady characters. Casting directors recognized his unique look and it definitely worked to his advantage. He landed roles in several major films including The Addams Family, Maverick, Ransom, and The Usual Suspects. One of his memorable portrayals was as Cher’s tough lawyer father in the beloved movie Clueless.


8. Keith David

Keith David
Number Of Projects: 57

Total Box Office: $1.5 billion

How He Owned The ’90s: Keith David, a classically-trained actor, made a mark in the ’90s not only through his powerful portrayals in live-action films but also for his remarkable voice work in Todd McFarlane’s Spawn and Gargoyles, where he voiced the main heroes. Throughout his career, which spans across film, television, video games, and animation, he has accumulated an impressive list of credits, earning him a special place in the hearts of multiple fandoms.


9. Whoopi Goldberg

Whoopi Goldberg
Number Of Projects: 58

Total Box Office: $2.5 billion

Whoopi Goldberg, a familiar face in the ’90s, could be considered more than just a character actor due to her immense fame. Despite her supporting roles, her presence cannot be ignored. Goldberg made a significant impact in comedies like Sister Act and Made in America, where her influential and charismatic performances left a lasting impression. However, she didn’t limit herself to comedic roles; the ’90s allowed her to showcase her dramatic skills in movies such as Sarafina!, Ghost, and Girl, Interrupted.

Similar to the late Robin Williams, Goldberg will be remembered for her comedic talent. Nevertheless, during this decade, she made it clear that she could excel in any genre. And let’s not forget her memorable voice acting as one of the villainous hyenas in The Lion King, a role that undoubtedly resonates with ’90s kids.


10. Peter MacNicol

Peter MacNicol
Peter MacNicol had an impressive presence in the 1990s, making his mark in Hollywood after his appearance in Ghostbusters II in 1989. He carried this momentum into the next decade, with a string of notable projects. Some of these include Addams Family Values, Bean, Chicago Hope, and Ally McBeal.

His portrayal of John Cage in Ally McBeal garnered critical acclaim and remains one of his most famous roles. This success is evident in his numerous accolades.

Throughout the ’90s, MacNicol was involved in a total of 24 projects, showcasing his versatility and talent. This extensive body of work contributed to his overall box office earnings, which amounted to an impressive $437 million.