Which Bart Simpson fan theory do you think is the most mind-blowing? Your opinions will help shape the discussion! Bart Simpson, known by various aliases such as Bartman and El Barto, has been causing mischief at Moe’s, saving or wreaking havoc on Springfield, and enduring his father’s strangling for over thirty seasons. In the early days of Springfield, he became famous for his iconic catchphrases, like “Don’t have a cow, man!” Back then, you could find his face plastered on all sorts of merchandise in a time before memes. However, as time has passed, Bart has evolved into something much greater, giving rise to some truly incredible fan theories.
Ever contemplated if Bart could be a member of the secret society, the Stonecutters? Or have you pondered the mystery behind his unique hairstyle? Perhaps you’ve even entertained the idea that he might secretly be the most intelligent Simpson sibling. Well, get ready for a wild ride! In this captivating list, we’ll be ranking the most jaw-dropping Bart Simpson fan theories out there. Share your thoughts on the theories that blow your mind and stay tuned for updates!
1. Bart Ruined Martin’s Education
In the early days of Sprinfieldian mythology, Bart caused significant harm to another character that lasted for many seasons. This occurred in the episode “Bart The Genius” (S1E2), where Bart switched his aptitude test with Martin’s, resulting in Martin being sent to a gifted school. As pointed out by Redditor /u/KuhlDota, Martin never recovered from this incident.
While Bart was eventually removed from the gifted school because he clearly didn’t belong there, Martin never had the opportunity to attend. Instead of progressing to a program that could have challenged and potentially benefited him, Martin has been stuck at the underperforming and deteriorating Springfield Elementary, receiving a consistently subpar education in the fourth grade. Bart’s cheating has essentially trapped Martin in this unfortunate situation.
2. Bart Simpson Is A Stone Cutter
In the episode “Homer the Great” (S6E12) of The Simpsons, Homer decides to join the Stonecutters, a secret society, after discovering that his father, Abe, is already a member. However, according to the theory put forward by Redditor /u/TyPiper93, it may actually be Bart who was the second member of the Simpson family to join.
The theory highlights a few interesting clues that support this idea. One example is a conversation at the dinner table where Homer mentions that Lenny and Karl are receiving special treatment at work. Bart’s response to this seems a bit evasive, raising the question of whether he knows something he’s keeping quiet about.
Another significant aspect to consider is the code for becoming a Stonecutter. Apart from having a blood relative who is already a member, the only other way to join is by saving a member’s life. In the episode “Blood Feud” (S2E22), Bart selflessly donates his blood to save Mr. Burns’ life. This aligns with the requirements of becoming a Stonecutter.
Lastly, the observant Redditor points out that Bart never seems to face any serious consequences at school, with detention being the worst punishment he receives. Could it be that he’s getting off easy because his brother, Principal Skinner, is also a member of the Stonecutters?
While this theory is just speculation, it raises intriguing questions about the possibility of Bart being a secret member of the Stonecutters.
3. Bart Isn’t Fooling Moe One Bit
A Redditor named /u/SenorSchnarf has an interesting theory about Moe Syzslak from The Simpsons. According to the theory, Moe might not be as gullible as he seems when it comes to prank calls. We all know that Bart constantly tricks Moe by making prank calls to his bar, using some of the simplest jokes a fourth grader can come up with. But what if Moe is actually aware of the pranks and plays along on purpose to entertain Bart, who happens to be the son of one of his best customers? It turns out that Moe truly loves Bart and is willing to make a fool of himself by participating in these pranks.
For example, one of Bart’s famous prank calls goes like this:
Bart: Can I speak to Mr. Jazz? His first name is Hugh.
Moe: Hugh Jazz? Let’s see if there’s a Hugh Jazz in the restroom.
It’s clear that Moe is not falling for the prank because he’s dumb, but rather because he wants to make Bart laugh. He happily plays along with these silly setups and punchlines, showing his affection for Bart.
4. Bart Is Actually A Genius
Look, the Simpsons are often seen as stupid, although Lisa stands out as an exception. As for Maggie, it’s too early to make a judgment. Marge, on the other hand, doesn’t possess the infamous ‘Simpson Gene’ that is explored in the episode “Lisa the Simpson” (Season 9, Episode 17). So really, it’s only Bart and Homer who are in question. But are they truly unintelligent? According to Redditor /u/kerbyklok, it’s all just an act.
In the episode “HOMЯ” (Season 12, Episode 9), we discover that Homer would actually be a smart individual if it weren’t for a crayon lodged up his nose, near his brain. Once the crayon is removed, his IQ increases by 50 points. However, this notion contradicts the concept of the ‘Simpson Gene’, which suggests that the intelligence of Simpson men (but not women) gradually declines as they age. So, which version is accurate? The Redditor proposes that neither is true and suggests that Bart and his father deliberately act foolish because it makes their lives easier. While Bart does engage in foolish behavior, he also manages to pull off clever pranks that a genuinely unintelligent person could never orchestrate. This is possible because, deep down, Bart is actually a genius pretending to be a fool.
5. Bart Put Homer In A Permanent Coma
In the episode “So It’s Come To This: A Simpsons Clip Show” (S4E18), Bart plays a prank on Homer by creating an explosively dangerous beer can. Unfortunately, things go awry and Homer ends up in a coma. This incident sets the stage for a clip show, where we get a recap of past episodes. At the end of the episode, Homer suddenly wakes up and starts strangling Bart. However, a Reddit user named /u/Hardtopickaname has an interesting theory suggesting that Homer never actually woke up.
According to this theory, Homer remains in a coma indefinitely, and every episode that aired after April 1993 is actually happening solely within Homer’s mind. The Redditor supports this idea by pointing out that the storylines become increasingly absurd after Bart puts Homer into his perpetual slumber. Additionally, there is a noticeable increase in celebrity guest appearances during this time, leading to the speculation that Homer is somehow absorbing information from his hospital room.
Perhaps Bart watches celebrity gossip shows or engages in one-sided conversations with his unresponsive father, keeping him updated on current events. Regardless of how it happens, the theory suggests that everything we see on screen is a product of Bart’s initial prank gone wrong.
6. Bart Created “The Simpsons”
This theory, you know, it’s a little bit like a chicken-and-egg situation. But, when you think about Bart’s creative side, it kind of starts to make sense. This Redditor named /u/JustEmbarrassing has this idea that The Simpsons is actually based on Bart’s childhood, and get this, it’s written by Bart himself as an adult. Like, whoa.
So, the theory goes like this: Bart, besides being all about comedy and stuff (like, hello, Krusty the Klown), has actually had a ton of creative success throughout the show. I mean, he won an Oscar at the Academy Awards for his short film called “Angry Dad.” And get this, he and Lisa even scored an Emmy for their episode of “Itchy and Scratchy.” That’s pretty impressive, right?
Now, I know what you might be thinking. In those flashforwards, Bart is often portrayed as a total loser. But wait, hold up. The theory suggests that those moments just come before his major success after he creates The Simpsons. So, it’s like, those glimpses into the future don’t really show the whole picture, you know?
It’s all a bit mind-boggling, but it definitely makes you think. Maybe, just maybe, Bart is the mastermind behind The Simpsons. Who would have thought, right?
7. Bart Created The Hypnotoad
A Redditor by the name of /u/coleburns815 has come up with an interesting theory about the origin of the Hypnotoad. If you’re not familiar with the Hypnotoad, it’s a character in the Futurama universe that has the ability to hypnotize. According to this theory, the Hypnotoad wouldn’t exist if Bart hadn’t released a toad into the Australian ecosystem in the episode “Bart vs. Australia” (S6E16). The idea is that the toad eventually evolved into the Hypnotoad we know today.
8. Bart & Nelson’s Clothing Connection
Since the early days of Springfield Elementary, Bart Simpson and Nelson Muntz have been engaged in an ongoing feud. While there have been occasional instances of collaboration between the two, Nelson has predominantly played the role of Bart’s antagonist. According to a theory put forth by Redditor /u/PrincipalBlackman, the show has consistently portrayed their relationship as a battle between good and evil. This theory highlights the fact that both Bart and Nelson often sport reddish tops and blue shorts, which symbolically aligns them as opposing forces. It is worth noting that while their outfits share similarities, Nelson’s distinct tattered vest sets him apart, ensuring that they are not dressed exactly alike.
9. Bart Is Smarter Than Lisa
In a rather speculative post, Redditor /u/mjk1093 suggests that Bart might be much smarter than Lisa, but is deliberately concealing his intelligence for unknown motives. This idea could be connected to another theory mentioned earlier, “Bart Is Actually A Genius,” but it brings a more specific angle to the discussion. Is it possible that Bart is keeping his high intellect a secret? It’s worth noting that Bart himself claims to be acquainted with the writings of Pablo Neruda in the episode “Bart Sells His Soul” (S7E4).
10. Bart Will Become An Agent Of Hell
There’s definitely something mischievous about Bart Simpson, although it’s usually presented in a playful way. According to Redditor /u/mirrorspirit, this notion may hold more truth than we think. Their theory suggests that Bart could potentially become an actual angel of hell after his time on Earth. While the specifics of this concept are a bit unclear, the underlying idea is that Bart’s rebellious nature, combined with his ability to combat corruption (like taking on Sideshow Bob or standing up against Whacking Day), would make him an ideal choice for the devil as a guardian of chaos.
11. Bart Repeated The Fourth Grade
In “Bart Gets an ‘F'” (S2E1), the school psychiatrist proposes that Bart should repeat the fourth grade due to his continuous failure on history tests. At the end of the episode, Bart miraculously achieves a D- on his last attempt, which technically makes him pass the test. However, a Redditor named /u/theWallflower presents an interesting perspective. They argue that this grade might not have been enough to secure Bart’s promotion to the fifth grade. According to this theory, the D- might have kept Bart stuck in Mrs. Krabappel’s classroom, explaining why he never moves on from her class. In fact, the passing grade could have been a mere fabrication, a coping mechanism Bart created to deal with the harsh reality that he would remain in fourth grade indefinitely.
