Here’s a compilation of the all-time greatest Big Brother contestants, whether they were strategic masterminds or simply a blast to watch. Prepare to be amazed by the true legends in this lineup.
One standout star is Dan Gheesling, whose Big Brother journey has been nothing short of remarkable. He triumphed in season 10 and secured the runner-up spot in season 14, solidifying his status as one of the most exceptional players in Big Brother history, if not the absolute best.
But let’s not confine ourselves to the well-known seasons. Feel free to include contestants from any season of Big Brother. You might want to consider beloved houseguests like Lisa Donahue or Marcellas Reynolds, or perhaps you’re more intrigued by those who accumulated the most victories.
This list showcases some of the craftiest, most audacious, and unforgettable contestants to ever grace the US version of Big Brother. Get ready to dive into a world of thrilling personalities and captivating gameplay.
1. Dan Gheesling
Dan Gheesling is a total legend in the Big Brother world. He’s got this insane strategic gameplay and charisma that just sets him apart from everyone else. I mean, the guy won Big Brother 10 and then came back for Big Brother 14 and got second place. That’s seriously impressive!
What makes Dan so incredible is his knack for manipulating and controlling the game. He’s got this uncanny ability to make moves that leave fans and fellow houseguests in awe. Seriously, the respect he commands is off the charts.
Age: 37
Dearborn, MI
2. Will Kirby
Dr. Will Kirby, also known as the “Evil Genius,” emerged victorious in Big Brother 2 and earned the title of winner. In a subsequent season, Big Brother 7, he made a comeback and secured fourth place. His ability to cleverly manipulate the game, combined with his charismatic personality, propelled him to become one of the most memorable and iconic players in the history of Big Brother.
Age: 50
Florence, Italy
3. Janelle Pierzina
Janelle Pierzina, often referred to as the “Queen” of Big Brother, is a legendary competitor who has taken part in three seasons of the show – Big Brother 6, Big Brother All-Stars, and Big Brother 14. What sets Janelle apart is her relentless competitive spirit, as she holds the record for the most competition wins in the game. Not only that, but her lively personality and exceptional social skills have made her a beloved figure among fans.
Age: 43
Grand Rapids, USA, Minnesota
4. Vanessa Rousso
Vanessa Rousso, a professional poker player, really showed off her strategic mind in Big Brother 17. She ended up finishing in third place, which is pretty impressive. One thing that people always remember about her is how emotional she could be during the game. But what really set her apart was her ability to outsmart her opponents. She had this amazing skill of planting seeds of doubt in their minds, and no one could match her in that. It’s no wonder she’s considered one of the best strategists around.
Age: 40
White Plains, New York, USA
5. Daniele Donato
Daniele Donato, the daughter of Evel Dick Donato, took part in both Big Brother 8 and Big Brother 13. She was quite the competitor, winning multiple competitions during her time on the show. Fans loved her for being brutally honest and playing the game with a lot of strength. Daniele truly stood out as a standout player and became a favorite among viewers.
Age: 37
Huntington Beach, California, USA
6. Kaysar Ridha
Kaysar Ridha, a player recognized for his strategic gameplay and charismatic charm, took part in three seasons of Big Brother – Big Brother 6, Big Brother All-Stars, and Big Brother 22. His reputation as an early mastermind is well-deserved, as Kaysar was never afraid to make daring moves while staying loyal to his alliances. It’s no wonder that he continues to hold a special place in the hearts of Big Brother fans.
Age: 43
Baghdad, Iraq
7. Rachel Reilly
Rachel Reilly, the winner of Big Brother 13 and a participant in Big Brother 12, is a well-known figure for her iconic catchphrase, “Floaters, grab a life vest!” Fans have truly appreciated Rachel’s gameplay, which is a perfect blend of passion and determination. She’s not afraid to wear her emotions on her sleeve, and her fierce attitude has won her the admiration of many. Rachel’s impressive track record of competition wins and her refusal to back down have solidified her status as one of the greatest houseguests in Big Brother history.
Age: 38
Concord, North Carolina, USA
8. Danielle Reyes
Danielle Reyes is often celebrated for her strategic gameplay in both Big Brother 3, where she came in second place, and Big Brother All-Stars. One of the reasons she gained popularity was her entertaining diary room confessionals, where she consistently impressed viewers with her quick wit and sense of humor. It’s safe to say that she is seen as one of the early trailblazers when it comes to strategic gameplay on the show.
9. Ian Terry
Ian Terry, who gained fame as the victor of Big Brother 14, made a lasting impression with his smarts and passion for the game. His strategic prowess led to some of the most daring moves of the season, solidifying his reputation as a formidable competitor. And there’s more! He even made a comeback in Big Brother 22, demonstrating his growth as a player and captivating audiences once again.
10. John Mcguire
Johnny Mac,” that’s the nickname people gave to John McGuire when he appeared on Big Brother 17. This guy really knew how to win over fans with his quirky personality and one-of-a-kind laugh. And when it came to competitions, John was no slouch. He had a knack for saving himself from eviction time and time again, thanks to his skill and determination. But it wasn’t just his gameplay that left a mark on the Big Brother community; it was also his offbeat charm and sense of humor. John was definitely a memorable character.
11. Evel Dick Donato
Evel Dick Donato, the winner of Big Brother 8, is undoubtedly one of the most controversial and unforgettable players ever seen on the show. With his ruthless gameplay and antagonistic approach, he left a lasting impression on viewers. Although he made a comeback for Big Brother 13, he unfortunately had to leave the game prematurely due to personal reasons. Love him or hate him, there’s no denying that Evel Dick has secured a distinct place in the annals of Big Brother history.
